A recent article by Drs. Zachary Meisel and Jeanmarie Perrone, who teach at the University of Pennsylvania Medical School, asks whether “conscientious and well trained” doctors are to blame for prescription drug abuse. The authors say “yes.” That is, they say doctors are partially to blame, but the authors stay silent on why anyone else might be. That silence is damning, the good professors’ assessment is wrong, and their article is of great concern.
Not only is Rx abuse far too complex a problem to “blame” on any one constituency, but even more critically, it is always unsettling and even scary when one or two members of a profession presume to apologize on behalf of their colleagues nationwide for some perceived wrong. Today across the country we are seeing what the White House Drug Czar has called an “epidemic” of Rx abuse. We are also in response seeing a misplaced, hamfisted law enforcement approach to what is, in all but the most extreme cases, a public health problem. Federal and state law enforcement agencies will only be emboldened by an article whose glittering generalities
help legitimize the illegitimate and ill-advised belief that routinely going after doctors for alleged criminal conduct is the solution.
So are doctors to blame? In PAINKILLER LAW’s view, no, except in the most extreme cases. If a healthcare provider screens a patient carefully, does a thorough exam and makes an informed diagnosis, prescribes within the boundaries of established safety for an approved drug, counsels the patient on the possibility of addiction, monitors the patient conscientiously, verifies with any available prescription drug database, and uses his or her best judgment about how the patient is doing, what is the basis for a criminal charge against that doctor in the event of addiction or an overdose? Can the authors enlighten us, please, before asserting that good doctors are partly to blame?
Who else might be to “blame?” Patients themselves? That notion borders on blasphemy within the White House Drug Czar‘s Office; don’t be “blaming the victim,” the reasoning goes. What about Big Pharma? The drug companies marketed the pain-relieving powers of Oxy and its many opioid cousins back in the late 1980′s and early 1990′s. Were they wrong about the pain-relief qualities of the medications? Did they purposely understate the potentially addictive qualities of the drugs? What about medical schools and the philosophical and educational change that took place around the same time, so that med students would be trained to acknowledge and treat severe pain? Should we indict your school’s Academic Senate?
The point is, it’s too easy, suspiciously easy, to blame doctors, and that’s precisely what should make folks like Professors Meisel and Perrone think twice and choose their words carefully before they effectively if inadvertently bless today’s ill-conceived law enforcement priorities. Because if they’ve ever written a pain scrip themselves, they may have just made what an excitable cop or prosecutor might call a confession.
PAINKILLER LAW: CRIMINAL LAW COMPLIANCE FOR HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS. 213.293.3737 firstname.lastname@example.org
The Meister Law Offices